Measure onboarding procedures success, and you’ll unlock the secret to building a productive, engaged, and loyal workforce. Did you know that organizations with a strong onboarding process improve new hire retention by 82% and productivity by over 70%? That’s according to a study by Glassdoor.
These numbers show that onboarding is about setting employees up to thrive from day one.
But how do you know if your onboarding program is really working? It’s not just about a new hire showing up on day two. You need measurable results like the employee retention rate, time-to-productivity, and meaningful onboarding feedback to evaluate and improve your process. In this post, we’ll walk you through 5 practical ways to measure onboarding success, so you can turn your onboarding program into a powerful tool for growth.
5 Best Ways to Measure Onboarding Success
Understanding the importance of measuring onboarding procedures success is one thing, but knowing how to measure it effectively is what really drives results. Below are the 5 best ways to evaluate whether your onboarding process is setting new employees up for success.
1. Employee Retention Rate
Retention is the clearest indicator of onboarding success. A strong onboarding process helps employees feel connected to their roles, teams, and the company’s mission, reducing turnover.
- How to Measure It:
- Calculate the percentage of new employees who stay with your company for a set period, such as 3 months, 6 months, or a year.
- Formula: (Number of new employees retained / Total number of new employees) x 100.
- Why It Matters: A high retention rate signals an effective onboarding process, while a low rate indicates new employees might feel unsupported or disengaged.
- Quick Tip: Track retention rates by department or role to pinpoint areas where onboarding might need improvement.
2. Time-to-Productivity
Time-to-productivity measures how long it takes for a new hire to become fully productive and meet their role’s expectations. The quicker employees ramp up, the more efficient your onboarding process.
- How to Measure It:
- Set clear performance benchmarks for new employees (e.g., sales targets, project completion timelines).
- Track the time it takes for employees to achieve these benchmarks.
- Why It Matters: If onboarding is effective, employees will understand their roles faster and start contributing sooner, leading to higher ROI.
- Quick Tip: Compare the productivity timelines of employees who underwent a structured onboarding program with those who didn’t.
3. Onboarding Feedback
Gathering feedback directly from new employees gives you valuable insights into how they perceive the onboarding experience. This is critical for identifying strengths and weaknesses in the process.
- How to Measure It:
- Use surveys, interviews, or anonymous questionnaires at key stages (e.g., after the first week, first month, and 90 days).
- Ask questions like:
- “How well did the onboarding process prepare you for your role?”
- “What areas of the onboarding procedures need improvement?”
- Why It Matters: Honest feedback helps you uncover gaps in training, communication, or resources that might hinder new employees’ success.
- Quick Tip: Act on feedback quickly. Showing employees that their input leads to improvement boosts morale and trust.
4. New Hire Engagement Levels
Employee engagement reflects a new hire’s level of commitment, motivation, and enthusiasm. High engagement during onboarding procedures ensures new employees feel connected and valued.
- How to Measure It:
- Conduct engagement surveys to measure indicators like satisfaction, motivation, and connection to the company culture.
- Look for behavioral signs: Are they actively participating in meetings? Do they ask questions and seek feedback?
- Why It Matters: Engaged employees are more likely to stay, perform well, and contribute to a positive work environment.
- Quick Tip: Pair new employees with mentors or buddies to strengthen engagement during onboarding.
5. Manager and Team Feedback
Managers and team members are valuable sources of input on a new hire’s performance and readiness. Their feedback helps determine whether onboarding effectively prepares employees for their roles.
- How to Measure It:
- Ask managers questions like:
- “Does the new hire understand their responsibilities?”
- “How prepared do they seem for their tasks?”
- Encourage team members to share observations about the new hire’s collaboration and communication.
- Ask managers questions like:
- Why It Matters: Managers and teams can spot skill gaps or areas where the onboarding process might need adjustment to better support new employees.
- Quick Tip: Schedule regular check-ins between managers and new employees to ensure alignment and address any concerns early.
When you track these five key metrics—employee retention rate, time-to-productivity, onboarding feedback, engagement levels, and manager input—you’ll gain a comprehensive view of your onboarding program’s success. Each method provides actionable insights that help you refine the process, improve the employee experience, and build a more productive team.
Tools and Strategies to Measure Onboarding Procedures Success
Measuring onboarding procedures success requires the right tools and strategies to collect, analyze, and act on data effectively. Thankfully, modern technology and structured processes make it easier to track key metrics and ensure your onboarding program delivers results. Here are the top tools and strategies you can implement:
1. Onboarding Software
Dedicated onboarding software automates processes, tracks progress and provides real-time insights into your onboarding program.
- What It Does:
- Track new hire activities, such as completing training modules or filling out necessary paperwork.
- Provides feedback tools like surveys and checklists.
- Generate reports to measure time-to-productivity and engagement.
- Top Tools to Try:
- NotchHR – A comprehensive HR platform that simplifies onboarding and tracks employee progress. It combines onboarding with performance management tools for seamless tracking.
- Why It Matters: Onboarding software saves time, reduces manual errors, and offers centralized data to measure success.
2. Employee Feedback Surveys
Structured surveys help you gather direct input from new employees about their onboarding experience.
- How to Use It:
- Distribute surveys at key milestones: the first week, 30 days, 60 days, and 90 days.
- Include a mix of quantitative (scale-based) and qualitative (open-ended) questions.
- Example Questions:
- “How confident do you feel in your role after onboarding? (1-5 scale)”
- “What was the most helpful part of the onboarding procedures?”
- Tools to Use:
- SurveyMonkey or Google Forms for customizable and easy-to-distribute surveys.
- Culture Amp for deeper employee engagement insights.
- Why It Matters: Surveys provide actionable feedback that highlights what’s working and where improvements are needed.
3. HR Analytics Platforms
HR analytics tools collect and analyze onboarding data to identify trends, measure retention, and evaluate productivity.
- How to Use It:
- Track metrics like employee retention rate, time-to-productivity, and engagement scores.
- Use dashboards to visualize data and identify areas for improvement.
- Top Tools to Try:
- NotchHR – Provides detailed insights into onboarding outcomes. It also tracks new hire performance that is integrated with HR analytics.
- Why It Matters: HR analytics tools offer data-driven insights, helping you make informed decisions to optimize onboarding.
4. Regular Check-Ins with Managers and Mentors
Manager and mentor feedback is invaluable for measuring a new hire’s progress and readiness.
- How to Implement It:
- Schedule weekly or bi-weekly check-ins between managers and new employees during the first 90 days.
- Use these sessions to discuss:
- Performance against initial goals.
- Challenges the new hire is facing.
- Overall satisfaction with onboarding.
- Why It Matters: Managers have a clear view of whether onboarding equips employees with the tools, knowledge, and confidence to succeed. Their feedback highlights areas needing improvement.
5. Employee Performance Tracking
Monitoring a new hire’s performance allows you to measure how effectively onboarding prepares them for success.
- How to Use It:
- Define clear, measurable performance goals for the first 30, 60, and 90 days.
- Use tools like Trello, Asana, or NotchHR to track task completion and milestones.
- Measure how quickly new employees reach expected productivity levels.
- Why It Matters: Performance tracking ensures new employees are progressing as expected and helps identify where additional training may be needed.
By combining these tools and strategies—onboarding software, feedback surveys, HR analytics, check-ins, and performance tracking, you create a data-driven approach to measuring onboarding procedures success. Not only will this help you refine your process, but it will also ensure new employees are engaged, productive, and ready to contribute.
Key Onboarding Metrics You Should Focus On
To truly measure onboarding success, you need to track specific metrics that offer actionable insights into how well your process is performing. By focusing on the right onboarding metrics, you can identify what’s working, what’s not, and adjust to optimize results. Here are the key metrics every company should measure:
1. Employee Retention Rate
Retention rate shows how many new employees stay with the company after a specific period. A strong onboarding process fosters loyalty and minimizes turnover.
- How to Track It:
- Measure retention at milestones such as 30 days, 90 days, and 1 year.
- Formula: (Number of employees retained / Total number of new employees) x 100.
- Why It Matters: Research by Glassdoor shows that effective onboarding can improve retention by 82%. If retention rates are low, your onboarding process may need adjustments to better support employees.
2. Time-to-Productivity
Time-to-productivity measures how quickly new employees reach full performance. Faster ramp-up times indicate an efficient onboarding process.
- How to Track It:
- Set clear performance goals for new employees.
- Track how long it takes for employees to meet their first milestones, such as completing a project or reaching a sales quota.
- Why It Matters: Lower time-to-productivity reduces training costs and accelerates ROI. A lengthy ramp-up period may suggest gaps in onboarding materials or training.
3. New Hire Engagement
Engagement measures how motivated and committed new employees are during and after onboarding. Highly engaged employees feel connected to their roles and the company.
- How to Track It:
- Use engagement surveys to measure enthusiasm, satisfaction, and motivation.
- Observe behaviors such as participation in meetings, proactive communication, and willingness to take on tasks.
- Why It Matters: A Gallup report found that engaged employees are 21% more productive and less likely to leave. Low engagement signals a need to strengthen onboarding activities like mentorship or team integration.
4. Onboarding Feedback Scores
Onboarding feedback scores give you direct insights into how new employees perceive the process. This metric highlights strengths and weaknesses from the employee’s perspective.
- How to Track It:
- Use post-onboarding surveys to collect quantitative (e.g., rating scales) and qualitative feedback.
- Focus on questions like:
- “How prepared do you feel for your role after onboarding?”
- “What aspects of onboarding were most or least helpful?”
- Why It Matters: Feedback scores help you fine-tune the onboarding experience. The more aligned the program is with employee needs, the better the outcomes.
5. 90-Day Performance Rate
The 90-day performance rate measures how well new employees meet their goals within their first three months. This is a strong indicator of onboarding effectiveness.
- How to Track It:
- Define specific performance benchmarks (e.g., completing projects, achieving KPIs).
- Track the percentage of employees who meet or exceed these benchmarks within 90 days.
- Why It Matters: High 90-day performance rates show that onboarding effectively equips employees to perform in their roles. Low rates suggest gaps in training or unclear expectations.
6. Turnover During Onboarding
Turnover during onboarding indicates that something in the process is not working, leading to early employee exits.
- How to Track It:
- Measure how many employees leave within the first 30, 60, or 90 days.
- Compare this to your overall turnover rate.
- Why It Matters: If turnover is high, it may point to issues like unmet expectations, lack of support, or poor cultural fit during onboarding.
When you track key onboarding metrics like retention rate, time-to-productivity, new hire engagement, onboarding feedback scores, 90-day performance rate, and turnover during onboarding—you get a clear picture of your onboarding program’s effectiveness. These ensure that new employees become confident, engaged, and productive members of your team.
Conclusion
Measuring your onboarding success is essential for creating a positive, long-term impact on employee satisfaction, retention, and productivity. When you focus on key metrics, you can pinpoint areas of improvement and fine-tune your process to ensure your new employees are set up for success.
Implementing the right tools will also provide you with actionable insights that help you continuously improve your onboarding program. The goal is simple: an onboarding experience that leads to motivated, productive, and engaged employees who are ready to contribute and stay for the long term.
At NotchHR, we understand the importance of efficient onboarding. NotchHR’s employee feedback tools and onboarding analytics allow you to collect and analyze data throughout the onboarding process, ensuring your program delivers the results you need. With customizable workflows and performance tracking features, NotchHR helps HR teams streamline their processes, reduce turnover, and boost new hire productivity.
If you’re looking to elevate your onboarding process with data-driven insights and seamless tracking, NotchHR is here to help you succeed. Optimize your onboarding program today and watch your new employees thrive.
Make onboarding effortless and effective. Book a demo with NotchHR and watch your new employees thrive from day one.
